The Report Format Changed Under You in January 2025

If your department is working from a Self-Assessment Report template that a senior colleague saved three years ago, it is the wrong template. NBA revised the SAR for Tier-I programmes in July 2024 and for Tier-II in January 2025, with a transition window that closed in June 2025. The old format is no longer accepted.

The revision aligns NBA with version 4.0 of the Graduate Attributes and Professional Competencies framework published by the International Engineering Alliance — the body behind the Washington Accord, which is what makes an Indian engineering degree legible abroad. This is not a cosmetic renumbering.

Twelve Programme Outcomes Became Eleven

The most consequential single change: the twelve POs everyone had mapped their courses against are now eleven. Old PO6 (The Engineer and Society) and old PO7 (Environment and Sustainability) merged into a single new PO6, The Engineer and the World.

Every CO-PO mapping matrix built against the old twelve is now mis-numbered. A department that re-labels the columns and moves on has not done the work: two outcomes that were assessed separately are now one, and the attainment evidence behind them has to be combined rather than concatenated. A twelve-column articulation matrix has to be migrated deliberately, never silently reinterpreted.

Nine Criteria, Not Ten

This one is worth stating carefully, because the wrong version is repeated almost everywhere online — including by people selling accreditation software.

The Tier-II SAR of January 2025 sets out nine criteria across 1000 marks: eight at programme level and one at institution level. The widely-published “ten criteria, seven programme and three institute” split describes the superseded format. If your preparation is organised against ten criteria, it is organised against a document NBA no longer assesses you on.

Tier-II covers engineering programmes at AICTE-approved colleges affiliated to a university — most of them. Tier-I is for autonomous institutions and university departments, and it is not a different framework: same nine criteria, same marks, an identical Criterion 5. Only Criterion 6 differs, along with one gate — Tier-II relaxes the three-year professor requirement where Tier-I does not.

There Is No Pass Mark

The second myth is more dangerous than the first, because it shapes how departments prioritise: the belief that 750 of 1000 buys six years and 600 buys three.

There is no aggregate threshold. The award is decided by the pattern of per-criterion grades together with the hard gates. Each criterion is graded as a percentage band of its own marks — fully compliant, concern, weakness, deficiency. A single Weakness blocks a six-year award. A single Deficiency blocks everything. Your total is not a currency you can spend to cover a weak criterion.

The practical consequence is the opposite of what a total-marks mental model suggests. Lifting a strong criterion from good to excellent buys nothing. Lifting your worst criterion out of the Weakness band is the whole game.

The Gates You Cannot Compute Your Way Past

Four gates sit outside the marks entirely, and each is pass or fail: the proportion of faculty holding a PhD, the student-faculty ratio, whether the required professors are regular appointments, and whether the head of department is a regular appointment with a PhD.

Every one is computable today from records you already hold, and none can be improved by software. A recruitment decision made two years before submission changes the outcome; a well-written report does not. Count your own faculty against the current thresholds before any effort goes into prose — a failed gate caps the award on its own, whatever the marks say.

Attainment Is Arithmetic, and Arithmetic Needs Records

Outcome-based accreditation asks a question documentation cannot answer by assertion: did students actually attain the outcomes the programme claims? The calculation runs from individual assessment items up through course outcomes to programme outcomes — arithmetic over marks the institution already recorded.

Which is exactly where it goes wrong. The failure is rarely conceptual; most departments understand attainment perfectly well. It is that the marks live in a lecturer's spreadsheet, internal assessment components were never stored apart from the total, and the question-to-CO map was written on paper once and lost. You cannot compute attainment retrospectively from a column of final marks.

  • Assessment items stored individually. Question-level or component-level marks, not just totals — attainment is computed per outcome, and outcomes map to questions.
  • The question-CO map lives with the assessment. Recorded when the paper is set, not reconstructed two years later by someone who did not set it.
  • Cohorts stable and traceable. The same students, identified the same way, across admission, examination and placement records — so the numbers in three criteria agree.

That chain is the design premise behind accreditation on EdPayU+: an attainment figure should trace back through the course outcome, the question, the script and the examiner who marked it. The report is derived, not assembled.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many criteria does the NBA Tier-II SAR have?

Nine, across 1000 marks — eight at programme level and one at institution level, per the Part B Criteria Summary of the January 2025 SAR. The “ten criteria” figure still circulating online belongs to the superseded format.

What total do I need for a six-year accreditation?

There is no aggregate pass mark. The award follows the per-criterion grade pattern and the hard gates: a single Weakness blocks six years, a single Deficiency blocks any award, irrespective of the total.

How many Programme Outcomes does NBA use now?

Eleven, under GAPC v4.0. Old PO6 (The Engineer and Society) and old PO7 (Environment and Sustainability) merged into the new PO6, The Engineer and the World.

Does NBA accredit the college or the programme?

The programme. Each programme is assessed and awarded its own term — a college does not hold a single institutional NBA status the way it holds a NAAC outcome.

The Test Worth Running This Week

Pick one course that ran last semester. Ask for its CO attainment, and for the question-level marks the figure was computed from. If it arrives the same day, the new SAR is a writing exercise. If it needs a week and three reminders, the format change did you a favour by exposing that now rather than in the month before submission.